The Liberty Guardian
November 25th, 2014
March 27, 2010 By: M.J. Harris Category: Liberty Blog

By Peter Schiff

In his latest weekly New York Times column, Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman put forward arguments that were so nonsensical that the award committee should ask for its medal back.

Recent rhetoric from Washington has put the economic relationship between the U.S. and China squarely on the front burner, and Krugman is demanding that we crank up the flame. This week 130 members of Congress sent a letter to Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner demanding that the Obama administration designate China as a “currency manipulator”. Following that, a bipartisan group of senators introduced a bill that looks to force the Obama administration’s hand. For its own part, Beijing invites criticism by continuing to deny its utterly obvious currency agenda.

As these tensions escalate, most economists urge Washington to tread lightly because of the negative fallout for America if China were to begin selling its enormous cache of U.S. Treasury bonds. Krugman pushes back, asserting that the U.S. risks little by playing hardball, and that China has more to lose. He asserts that a Chinese decision to end its purchases of U.S. Treasury debt would make only a marginal impact on long-term interest rates. Did you hear that Stockholm?

According to Krugman, our secret weapon of economic invincibility is the Fed’s ability to print dollars endlessly. If China were to foolishly decide to attack us by selling our debt, the Fed could simply step in and buy the excess with newly printed greenbacks. (In other words, Krugman sees no difference between funding the debt and monetizing it. See my latest video blog on the subject.). For Krugman, China would gain little from such an attack, but would lose the ability to export to its best customer and suffer severe losses in the value of its dollar holdings. Krugman’s worldview is reassuring – but it has absolutely nothing to do with reality.

There is a huge difference between selling your debt to another and “selling” it to yourself. When China buys our debt, it uses its own savings. In order to purchase a trillion dollars of U.S. Treasuries, the Fed would have to expand our money supply by a corresponding amount. Even Krugman acknowledges that this would cause the dollar to lose value; however, he feels that a weaker dollar is good for America and bad for China.

Krugman does not believe that a tanking dollar will translate into higher interest rates or higher consumer prices at home. No matter how many dollars the Fed creates, or how much value those dollars lose relative to other currencies, he is confident that as long as unemployment remains high, rates will stay low and inflation will remain under control. This is absurd.

If the dollar were to nosedive, the Fed would normally look to protect the currency by raising interest rates, thereby increasing foreign demand for the currency. But with an economy currently on crutches, the Fed will ignore a weakening dollar and continue to try to boost employment with near-zero rates.

But keeping the Fed Funds rate low only holds rates down for U.S. government debt. If the dollar weakens substantially, other rates offered to other borrowers will rise as investors demand greater returns to compensate for inflation. To keep rates low for homeowners, credit card borrowers, corporations, municipalities, and state governments, the Fed would be forced to buy, or guarantee, all forms of dollar-denominated debt. The Fed would become the lender of only resort.

Once the Fed shows that its commitment to low rates is limitless (the value of the dollar be damned), private creditors will quit the game. Even average Americans would hit the Fed’s bid. It would be a race for the exits, with no one wanting to be left holding a bag of worthless paper dollars.

Most economists, Krugman included, see cheap money as a panacea for all ills. And while it’s true that a falling dollar, by lowering the real value of U.S. wages, would help make U.S. goods more competitive, it would also lead to skyrocketing consumer prices, rapidly rising interest rates, and a collapse in American living standards. Make no mistake: this is the end game of Krugman’s “get tough on China” policy.

This apocalyptic scenario can only be avoided if Washington jealously guards the status quo, avoiding confrontation with China at all costs. Yet, even that is an outcome that no one can rationally expect. Given exploding U.S. government deficits and the inability of U.S. citizens and corporations to repair their balance sheets, the United States faces financing needs that even China’s gargantuan savings stockpile will be unable to cover.

Krugman is right about one thing – China’s currency peg is destabilizing the global economy and must end. But he fails utterly to understand the implications for the U.S. and China. If China were to reverse its role in the U.S. Treasury market, both economies would be destabilized in the short-term. But in the medium- and long-term, China would clearly emerge as the winner.

Absent Treasury-bond purchases, the value of the Chinese currency would rise sharply, causing goods prices to tumble in China. This long-delayed increase in purchasing power for everyday Chinese will unleash pent-up demand in what is already the largest middle class in the world. Chinese factories would retool in order to produce goods for their own citizens to consume. In RMB terms, commodity prices would plunge, making it easier for China to produce all kinds of stuff, such as automobiles, while also making it cheaper for the Chinese to buy gas. Millions will trade in bikes for cars, and Chinese oil imports will swell.

The opposite would occur in America, where an artificial, consumer-based economy, supported by Chinese lending, will come tumbling down. Without the ability to import cheap goods from overseas, Americans will pay more and get less. While gas and food become cheaper for the Chinese, they will simultaneously become much more expensive for Americans – so too will automobiles, consumer electronics, furniture, and just about every other product we want or need (even those few we still make ourselves).

Washington’s best option is to recognize that the current relationship is unsustainable and to plan, as best as possible, for a more viable future. We Americans also must be honest with ourselves and recognize that we have been living beyond our means and that our lifestyle has been largely financed by austerity in China. We must conceive of a plan that weans us from this dependence without provoking China to pull the rug out from under us before we have a firm footing. To construct a policy around Krugman’s ridiculous assumption that we benefit China more than they benefit us is to invite catastrophe on an unimaginable scale.

14 Responses

  1. TraVotez Said,

    [...] (86)  Paul Krugman y la realidad [...]

    Posted on April 2nd, 2010 at 1:24 am

  2. Longchamp Le Pliage Hobo Bags Said,

    a absence of imagination the final third desperately needs addressing. #RUS 1-1 #KOR Dzagoev and Kerzhakov have had a affirmative impact from the pew for #RUS: http://t.8 percentage from the field and an uncharacteristic 69. 51. George Libretti, also are hoping for one more shot at the huge phase Andre Johnson was never new as the Texans began workouts for the Pro Bowl wideout continues his offseason battle with the troop. “He earned it with his preparation, “Maybe I’m biased because I see alway

    Posted on June 18th, 2014 at 11:38 pm

  3. ANSI Z245.1-2008 Said,

    Simply put,ANSI C78.376-1997, it really doesn have to do with protecting Russians there. I want to assure you,ANSI MH1-2005, however,ANSI MH14.1-1987, that the safety of our students is always our top priority.. Building on the Trendline equipment line,ANSI Z55.1-67, the Highline is upgraded by features such as part chrome mirror housings,ANSI IT9.11-1998, various chrome accents outside and inside the vehicle and fender skirt extensions in body colour that create space for 17 inch aluminium whee

    Posted on October 12th, 2014 at 9:58 pm

  4. ugg sheepskin cuff boot Said,

    I tested a Razer Naga (regular) and the side keys did not work at all. I had the Mae Un Dak Bok Um a chicken stir fry with cabbage,ugg sheepskin cuff 1875, carrots,ugg sheepskin cuff 1875, peppers in a spicy sauce. The music is melodic and entertaining with some nice highlights which include the melodic “Yor’s Theme”, a lush romance in “At The Waterfall”,ugg sheepskin cuff boots, and pure action in “The Revolution Begins” and “Final Battle/Race To The Shuttle”,ugg sheepskin cuff boots 1875. Cran

    Posted on October 15th, 2014 at 8:47 pm

  5. ANSI B175.1-2000 Said,

    Entries must comply with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations. Other reasons rising to all time highs were “could not afford first choice” and “not offered aid by their first choice.”. You see, anti gun groups don’t seem to see that they can’t have it both ways,ugg adirondack boot, punishing anyone who is found guilty using a gun to the maximum and full extent and then crying foul when those same laws are applied to a case they find sympathetic.. There are three important terminologies th

    Posted on October 16th, 2014 at 7:55 pm

  6. IPC 1752A Said,

    Product sales for the three months ended September 30, 2012 were $2.2 million compared to $2.1 million for the same period in 2011. To cast the alloy,ugg sheepskin cuff 1875, you have to heat it well into the liquid range. Maurice LaMarche: LaMarche has been doing character voices and impressions since his childhood. The Leaf has a range of about 100 miles. As shown in the first figure on the left the input bits are first grouped and assigned for transmission over different frequencies (sub carr

    Posted on October 16th, 2014 at 7:55 pm

  7. API 510 Said,

    It not like everything in the books has to be “realistic”. Dany has a plot shield, Arya has a plot shield, Tyrion has a plot shield, a lot of event such as the Red wedding are “unlikely” to happen. “Last year it was 30,000. This year it’s predicted to lose 100,000. Luego de permitir slo dos imparables en la victoria por 2 1 en el primer juego de la serie de tres en el Tropicana Field, los lanzadores de los Rays siguieron intratables. Limitaron a los Orioles a cuatro sencillos para vencer a los a

    Posted on October 28th, 2014 at 9:02 pm

  8. API Std 599 Said,

    Bedrooms are tremendous value and full of uncluttered country inn elegance. You’ll find lovely old furniture, soft coloured walls, free standing Victorian baths, huge shower heads,API MPMS Chapter 17.9, crisp linen, fluffy bathrobes and handmade soaps. If you any kind of action manga fan,API RP 1637 (R2012), and you haven read Gunsmith Cats. Why are you still sitting there? Come on, it 450+ pages for less than twenty bucks,API Publ 4776, and there two other volumes before this! The real question

    Posted on October 29th, 2014 at 9:41 pm

  9. API Std 603 Said,

    CFPs use CFP and the CFP marks on business cards and stationery. CFP students must understand financial principles and investments,API RP 44. The Toledo built Cherokee, new for the 2014 model year, replaced the Liberty in Jeep lineup. It is an important vehicle for Chrysler Group LLC both in the United States and abroad, figuring to play a big role in the company goal of selling one million Jeeps worldwide in this year. Education is also required. Both for the cyclists and for the motorists. Whe

    Posted on October 29th, 2014 at 10:20 pm

  10. http://www.beltfinancial.com/ Said,

    No biggie,ugg sheepskin cuff boot black,” I thought. The movie is rather poetic and at times, quite moving. The last operating income margin on those sales was about $0.28 on the dollar and as we have said before this is a little bit higher than what we would like. The other book that I can recommend is called “Wheels for the World” by Doug Brinkley. Before they publicly do that,IPC 9701A, DURECT needs to further analyze the information in the CRL and then meet face to face with the FDA in a few

    Posted on October 30th, 2014 at 7:52 pm

  11. AATCC EP2-2002 Said,

    As an Administrator I’ve often used scripts to automate regular tasks. The segments show the man described as light skinned and between 5 feet 8 inches and 6 feet tall walking through the gas station before and after the stabbing, police said.. He envisioned art as a product of the human mind,AATCC EP4-2007, of reason,AATCC 173-1998, or “cosa mentale” as he would say in his mother tongue, Italian. I love ALL kinds of music. Isn’t this going a bit too far for consumer electronics? We expect this

    Posted on November 4th, 2014 at 9:47 pm

  12. ASHRAE F25-2009 (I-P) Said,

    Americans did cut down proportionally on fats but, ironically, they started to get fatter much fatter. Statistics from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention show that rates of obesity in children and adults, which had been climbing through the ’70s, started to shoot upward around 1980. For children, obesity tripled from about 5 percent in 1980 to about 15 percent in 2000. Working at Restaurants or Stores: Many restaurants,ANSI/ASHRAE 137-2009, fast food outlets,ASHRAE 94.1-2010, and ice

    Posted on November 6th, 2014 at 8:23 pm

  13. kids ugg Said,

    Think about the time spent waiting for a green light. During this wait,ugg erin baby boots, the engine would shut its self off and when the brake pedal or clutch is released the engine restarts with the driver almost unable to detect the transition. This system has been commonly used in Europe since 2007 and is slowly making its way into more and more models in North America including the 2013 Fusion 1.6.. It may take a few listens for it to grow, but it works.of Hope and Dreams was the standard

    Posted on November 6th, 2014 at 10:01 pm

  14. UL 1256 Said,

    We dont know what we are eating and most likely if we saw the contents and processes used to create these frankenfoods,AWS A5.18/A5.18M, we would be horrified. Processed foods,AWS A5.16/A5.16M, and I use the term food lightly,UL 1694, lining the shelves of our grocery stores have little actual food in them. A reading of a simple label on a box will leave you dazed and confused.,AWS A5.1/A5.1M. That question has been answered. Hollywood Reporter has announced that Abrams has cast Russian born act

    Posted on November 14th, 2014 at 9:46 pm

Add A Comment

Your Ad Here