The Liberty Guardian
October 9th, 2015
March 27, 2010 By: M.J. Harris Category: Liberty Blog

By Ed Kaitz

via: The American Thinker

Nancy Pelosi wants to give birth to a new kind of freedom in America — the freedom from being “job-locked.”

In an interview with Rachel Maddow Thursday evening, Pelosi asked Americans to “think” about a bright, new, liberating kind of utopia:

Think of an economy where people could be an artist or a photographer, a writer without worrying about keeping their day job in order to have health insurance. Or that people could start a business and be entrepreneurial and take risks, but not be job-locked because a child has a child has asthma or diabetes or someone in the family is bipolar. You name it, any condition is job-locking.

Maddow was so overwhelmed and smitten with Pelosi’s remarks that she posted the interview on her website under the following title: “Finally! Pelosi frames health reform for the win. (Hint: It’s about freedom.)”

The problem with Pelosi’s remarks, however, is that from hindsight, they are not bright, new, or liberating. On the contrary, almost identical words were penned over a hundred years ago by another champion of economic “freedom”: Karl Marx. Marx criticized the private economy because it led to the “renunciation of life and of human needs.”

Like Pelosi, Marx was deeply troubled by an economic system that left most people job-locked and unable to satisfy their “human need” to become more authentic. In other words, the more you have to work, said Marx, “the less you eat, drink, buy books, go to the theater or to balls, or to the public house, and the less you think, love, theorize, sing, paint, fence, etc.”

Marx chastised the middle class in England for being “so incurably debased by self-interest” and thirsty for a “quick profit” that they were incapable of recognizing the alienation from their true selves. Communist society, then, was the cure that could liberate us from our false selves and usher in a new kind of creativity and authenticity. Says Marx:

Communist society … regulates the general production and thus makes it possible for me to do one thing today and another tomorrow, to hunt in the morning, fish in the afternoon, rear cattle in the evening, criticize after dinner, as the spirit moves me …”

This kind of sheer lunacy could have been hatched only by an unemployed academic and journalist like Marx, who, by the way, was supported financially in his authentically job-liberated struggle against capitalism by his wealthy colleague Friedrich Engels. What’s most disturbing is the number of wild-eyed crusaders, both then and now, who have fallen for Marx’s creative definition of “freedom.”

As for that nagging issue of just how “communist society” will “regulate the general production” after the socialist revolution, Engels had this to say:

The community will have to calculate what it can produce with the means at its disposal; and in accordance with the relationship of this productive power to the mass of consumers it will determine how far it has to raise or lower production.

In other words, leave it to the “community” (government) to worry about levels of production and consumption in order for the newly liberated and formerly “job-locked” citizens to pursue their lifelong dreams of being artists, writers, or photographers.

Friedrich Hayek wrote about this subtle shift in the word “freedom” over sixty years ago. He argued that as socialists began coming under fire for promoting servitude and control, they made the creative decision to harness to their “cart the strongest of all political motives — the craving for freedom.” For Hayek,

The subtle change in meaning to which the word ‘freedom’ was subjected in order that this argument sound plausible is important. To the great apostles of political freedom the word had meant freedom from coercion, freedom from the arbitrary power of other men, release from the ties which left the individual no choice but obedience to the orders of a superior to whom he was attached.

For the socialists, however, “before man could be truly free, the ‘despotism of physical want’ had to be broken, the ‘restraints of the economic system’ relaxed.” For Hayek, this new definition of freedom was “another name for the old demand for an equal distribution of wealth.”

Hayek asks a fascinating question that each and every American needs to consider before deciding whether to return any Obamacare-supporting politician to power this fall:

Who can seriously doubt … that the power which a multi-millionaire, who may be my neighbor and perhaps my employer, has over me is very much less than that which the smallest [bureaucrat] possess who wields the coercive power of the state and on whose discretion it depends whether and how I am to be allowed to live or to work?

Nancy Pelosi’s theory of “economic freedom,” you see, requires legions of new bureaucrats wielding the power of the state so that you can be liberated from your inauthentic, job-locked selves. If we take freedom in its true meaning — as freedom from coercion — we see instantly, however, that indeed, I am less coerced by a neighboring millionaire than by the tiniest government bureaucrat deciding where and when I can see a doctor, go to school, or become job-locked.

Years ago, before he died, I asked my father what he liked most about working in the home-building industry. After having been “job-locked” in the housing industry for over twenty years, he told me the following: “For me, the best thing of all is seeing a new family move into one of our homes.”

My father wasn’t a writer or an artist, but he was a kind, decent, hardworking man who loved his job and his family. Rather than struggle against the system and neglect his children like Marx did, my father felt it was part of his job, not the government’s, to take care of his family — including our health care.

Sounds pretty authentic to me.

16 Responses

  1. Tweets that mention The Meaning Of Freedom According To Marx | The Liberty Guardian -- Said,

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Becky Chandler. Becky Chandler said: Nancy Pelosi shares the same understanding of "freedom" as did Karl Marx [...]

    Posted on March 29th, 2010 at 3:00 am

  2. FreedoMonkey Said,

    Fantastic. :)

    Posted on October 7th, 2010 at 4:43 pm

  3. Darthstoner Said,

    This is Tripe, and how did it go keeping those Obamacare supporters out? lol

    Posted on April 14th, 2013 at 10:27 pm

  4. LibertarianGuy Said,

    Pretty shallow and not really an accurate depiction of Marx’s views on freedom. Besides the irrelevant personal attacks on Marx, Marx’s ideas were actually pretty reasonable for the time and conditions he was living in where the standard of life for workers was truly very horrible and much more reasonable than the socialism being peddled around by the far left right now. Something tells me you should go reread your Marx.

    Posted on April 29th, 2013 at 5:56 pm

  5. ANSI B3.2-1992 Said,

    There are many girls out there who have grown up with the dream to become an air hostess. Sometimes, you don’t even need a pan at all. 3 fire room, but without consideration of his own safety,ANSI B3.2-1992, passed Daly on and then assisted in rescuing another injured man from No. SweetBerry Fresh Market MEAT SAVINGS! DELI SAVINGS! Old Tyme Deli f. Since December 2003,ugg adirondack sale, he is the Chairman of the Board of BRP Inc. The refrigerator is really a refreshment center where you are ch

    Posted on October 13th, 2014 at 10:13 pm

  6. ANSI B74.12-2001 Said,

    Estimation of Endotoxin Inhalation from Shower and Humidifier Exposure Reveals Potential Risk to Human Health. Some athletes use creatine as a means of gaining weight, although the weight results from water retention rather than muscle mass,ANSI B77.1-2006, and therefore increases your likelihood of dehydration. A person who is laid back will like a dog that is quiet and doesn’t do too much running around.,ANSI B71.4-2004. The last of the figures is “Dr. Your child tells you about the first ever

    Posted on October 13th, 2014 at 10:22 pm

  7. UL 499 Said,

    EVANS BROWN: At Center Woods, the first standards based report card went out last Friday. Principal Potter says she’ll be spending this week helping parents adjust to the new grades. For NPR News, I’m Sam Evans Brown in Concord, New Hampshire. But you know what makes all of that a footnote? Having to be stuck in this situation while putting up with an asshole like Rhodes. Really, there so few of us left and you threatening to kill anyone that doesn do exactly what you want. Crude,uggs fox fur bo

    Posted on October 15th, 2014 at 8:10 pm

  8. API TR 17TR3 Said,

    EPRI standards have been developed and adopted in a number of areas, particularly within the semiconductor equipment industry. Relating to or being compositions or a composition performed on synthesizers or synthesized instruments. So, if you don’t eat enough,API Spec 6AV1, fewer calories will be burnt andhere will be less fat loss. You should eat small meals at regular intervals to keep your energy levels high. Digital games have been of interest to teachers and researchers since the first comm

    Posted on November 4th, 2014 at 2:43 am

  9. API TR 17TR4 Said,

    The limit on their power is not well defined and their role is somewhat broad. That means their impact is potentially far reaching. Sure, it’s crazy but crazy enough that it might just work! All you need is an army, a navy, and the support of the world community many of whom protect these small nations from intruders. This has been attempted in the Comoros, Vanuatu,API TR 2567, and the Maldives, but ultimately failed.[2]. Congratulations, you’ve taken a burgeoning suburban area and its ability t

    Posted on November 4th, 2014 at 2:58 am

  10. ANSI/API Std 6DX Said,

    My latest book is Estate Planning Smarts a guide for baby boomers and their parents,API RP 9B. This contributor’s page will cover the broad range of topics that affect boomers as they approach retirement age. In 1940, however,API TR 409, Churchill, alarmed by the possibility of ‘fifth columnists’ among the many German speaking refugees, decided to “collar the lot” and sent many between the ages of 16 and 65 as “enemy aliens” to internment camps in Canada and Australia. Alfred,API RP 17L2, just 1

    Posted on November 4th, 2014 at 7:34 pm

  11. API Publ 4776 Said,

    Dollar as its currency. Real estate, too,API RP 1637 (R2012), is an absolute bargain. There is no doubt that in Colorado the Abatement Industry is BIG business. Millions of dollars are spent each year on the safe removal of hazardous materials such as Asbestos and Lead for renovation as well as demolition. Jane Martin eyes truly are a bright blue sky and the one that McQueen is fighting for. The Blob,API Publ 4776, itself, glistens in the darkness and is completely translucent when it needs to b

    Posted on November 5th, 2014 at 8:33 pm

  12. ASME MFC-5.1-2011 Said,

    mats zuccarello could be within two weeks of return,ASME A90.1-2009Joffrey looks really scared for a second, and maybe even conflicted,ASME MFC-21.2-2010, but then he leaves. YOU SUCK. C lorsque vous l vous n pas besoin d le coteux CD original jeu blu ray,ASME B89.1.7-2009, juste besoin d des roms de jeux libres. Vous serez invincible dans le jeu cause des effets spciaux tout en n jamais connu une telle sensation extraordinaire. He was John’s first violin teacher. Each varnished beauty, some who

    Posted on November 10th, 2014 at 6:53 pm

  13. IPC J-STD-001E Said,

    We’ll get around to discussing when air conditioning isn’t a more efficient option,AAMI 14937, but let’s first take a look at what the SAE found.. The fluid should either steadily flow from this bung (so be ready to quickly put the bung back in),IPC 7351A, or this should be just level. Traffic on the internet is a series of hops from router to router and network to network,IPC 1752A, and in Tor each network node has only the name of the relay it was handed the information from and the relay it h

    Posted on November 24th, 2014 at 7:41 pm

  14. SAE J 1944 Said,

    In 2003, he was appointed by President George W. Bush to the National Security Telecommunications Advisory Committee. In 2006,SAE J 2719, he was elected a member of the TRW Automotive board of directors; received the Semper Fidelis Award from the Marine Corps Scholarship Foundation; and was elected a member of the Aerospace Industries Association Board of Governors Executive Committee. Real science is not at all dramatic. It involves a lot of paperwork,SAE AS 5663A, networking,ugg infant boots,

    Posted on November 27th, 2014 at 10:03 pm

  15. SAE AS 3255C Said,

    poem “The Tyger” is a complement to “The Lamb” of the world of innocence. Whereas in “The Lamb” the narrator is sure that a meek and mild God must have made the lamb,SAE AMS 5576K, in “The Tyger” the narrator is baffled at who could have made such a fearful creature as a tiger. The narrator asks,ASME Y14.5.1M-1994 (R2012), “Did he who made the lamb make thee?”(59). Dina Meyer is a dead ringer for Batgirl/Barbara Gordon and her calm,SAE J 2551-1, controlled personality was the balance to Ashley S

    Posted on December 2nd, 2014 at 12:30 am


    The author has not understood the vision of Marx. The author reduces Marx to the status of the author’s father who did not realize the limitations imposed on his life by the capitalistic economic order that compels every man to work interminably.

    Posted on April 21st, 2015 at 12:22 pm

Add A Comment

Your Ad Here