The Liberty Guardian
January 26th, 2015
June 04, 2010 By: M.J. Harris Category: Liberty Blog

by Megan McArdle

Like many of you, I’ve been (privately) making fun of the strain of thought that Barack Obama is a Bad President because he isn’t Doing Something!!!! About the BP Oil Spill!

I’ve been laughing even harder at those who acknowledge that he maybe can’t personally pilot a top secret experimental navy sub down to the well and close it himself (a la Bill Pullman in Independence Day), but castigate him anyway for not showing us that he “gets it”–it being the scope of the disaster, the deep moral seriousness of the crisis. Presumably, this would all be much easier to take if the president were openly panicking. Or something. The Care Bear Stare Model of American Politics once again rears its ugly head.

However, a friend writes that there might be something the President could and should do:

My father, who has worked in the petrochemical industry for decades, tells me that there is a well-established method for dealing with a problem like this: blowing up the well. It’s been done before, successfully. So why isn’t this option being actively considered, despite the failure of every method tried so far? Because when a well is blown up, it can’t ever be used again. As a result, BP stands to lose a lot from doing so. And they probably won’t have to pay for all the harm done by the oil spill. (Did you know the Exxon Valdez legal case just ended recently, after Exxon fought to keep every penny it could for years on end?)

So in a case like this, it seems like there’s a good argument for the president stepping in. BP has a poor incentive to do the right thing here. Now, it might be true — as Obama has said — that the government lacks the expertise and equipment to cap a well. But (a) capping a well and blowing it up aren’t the same thing, and (b) if blowing it up requires expertise the government lacks, they could just hire the experts from (say) other oil companies.

As for whether the government has the authority to step in, I think the answer is yes. There is an *ongoing* threat to property throughout the Gulf region, and the protection of property is well within what I consider proper government
action. Also, the seabed is not owned by BP — it’s property of the government, leased out to BP (or so I understand).

As I told my father, I don’t know enough about the risks of exploding a well to know for sure that it’s the best decision. For all I know, there’s a chance it would make the problem even worse. But it doesn’t seem like BP’s incentives are properly aligned for them to give it the proper consideration.

Unlike many in the blogosphere, I did not have enough boxtops to get my Petrochemical Marine Engineer Secret Decoder Ring, so I cannot weigh in on whether or not this is a good idea.

But if it is an idea that should be on the table, then I quite agree that the President–or rather, experts in his administration–should step in and make that decision. I’m pretty fond of America’s modern, fossil-fuel based economy, but I’m pretty sure it can survive the loss of one well. BP is undoubtedly willing to cost the rest of the country a near infinite sum to preserve its future profits. But in a case like this, with an enormous and crystal-clear negative externality being imposed on the rest of the country (and a large swathe of marine life), they shouldn’t have the power to make that decision.

From TheAtlantic – shaping the national debate on the most critical issues of our times, from politics, business, and the economy, to technology, arts, and culture.

13 Responses

  1. Tweets that mention Is Deepwater Horizon Not Being Blown Up Because BP Secretly Hopes To Drill From It Again? | The Liberty Guardian -- Said,

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by robert fleming, The Liberty Guardian. The Liberty Guardian said: Is Deepwater Horizon Not Being Blown Up Because BP Secretly Hopes To Drill From It Again? [...]

    Posted on June 4th, 2010 at 11:45 pm

  2. UL 174 Said,

    After reports that New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo plans to make the Empire State the 21st state to allow use of medical marijuana, the passage of a new law in Illinois and a petition in Florida to legalize medical cannabis, a variety of marijuana linked stocks have been on the rise. The Emaan and Terram battle their way to the elevator and Kei and Olson make their way up to the Daitokuiten to find their younger selves and the space/time oscillation bomb before it detonated. Kei and Olson understand

    Posted on October 10th, 2014 at 9:01 pm

  3. ANSI Z80.18-2010 Said,

    Critics claim that the MPAA is far more permissive of violence in PG 13 films than fleeting nudity or a handful of expletives.. So far, only six states mark non compliant IDs as such,ANSI C78.1418-1991, including Indiana, Connecticut, Delaware, Utah,ANSI B92.1-1996, West Virginia and Maryland. The Ark’s lawyer,ANSI Z245.51-2008, , noted that lawmakers are looking at possible moratoriums on using those tests for high stakes decisions.. Attend an Open House,ANSI C93.5-1997, meet your future profes

    Posted on October 12th, 2014 at 9:36 pm

  4. API SPEC 6D Said,

    One final note: do not use personal accounts when deploying SharePoint. The Setup User Account becomes owner of the SharePoint farm. The Farm Account becomes dbowner of the SharePoint Config database. ScienceDaily,ugg adirondack boot uk, 7 January 2005. .A Cup of Coffee a Day May Keep Retinal Damage Away, Study Shows May 2,ugg adirondack boot ii otter, 2014 Coffee drinkers, rejoice! Aside from java’s energy jolt, food scientists say you may reap another health benefit from a daily cup of joe: pr

    Posted on October 12th, 2014 at 9:50 pm

  5. API MPMS Chapter 5.3 Said,

    In contrast, the excellent survival high ESR1 groups exhibit low chemokine levels. However,API STD 653, even though the chemokine pathway is on average higher in expression in lowERHS than in lowERNS, it is likely not the only determining factor. The low ERNS group is comprised of 3 smaller sub networks and the chemokine activity varies between them, indicating that there are more sub groups within the lowERNS.. Olive oil is predominantly rich in heart healthy monounsaturated fat, which decrease

    Posted on October 13th, 2014 at 9:04 pm

  6. API Std 650 Said,

    For example,API MPMS Chapter 14.7, they may use a time clock,ANSI/API RP 554 Part 3, have a timekeeper keep track of employee’s work hours or tell their workers to write their own times on the records.” That being said, there exist no federal rules concerning the use of time clocks for salaried employees. It’s up to the employer to determine the best system of timekeeping for its employees.. Le sport cest autre chose que ca. Le plus scandaleux cest pendant leur carriere active quils passent en m

    Posted on November 2nd, 2014 at 11:08 pm

  7. API 1951 Said,

    Of Maldives (Just a 10 minute boat ride from Male International Airport.),API Publ 7104, +960 3338527,API Std 6A718, [2]. Best for an island vacation in budget price. Ideologues of all persuasions think they know how the economy will respond to the Administration’s strange mixture of Lafferism and monetarism. Indeed,API 2519D, their self confidence is so vast,API TR 409, and their ability to rationalize so crafty, that one cannot imagine a scenario for the next few years,API TR 6F1, that they wo

    Posted on November 4th, 2014 at 3:11 am

  8. ASME SI-3 Said,

    mucinex d mucinex mucinex dmAnd in addition as a development of an whole lifetime producing involving footwear frustration to be superior to folks to of all you captivating place. A urge unswerving that. In this study,ASME BPVUM, after SRIF administration, the total sleep time and REMS decreased and more time was spent awake in the first sleep cycle. We discussed that SRIF may become more effective in sleep EEG in older than in younger subjects because of the decline of GHRH axis activity.. 3, 2

    Posted on November 4th, 2014 at 4:04 am

  9. ASME B18.31.5-2011 Said,

    Much of what does come up in connection to the Carthaginians, moreover, is indeed quite positive. The naturalist Pliny the Elder alluded to the Carthaginians as great merchandisers, and Aristotle and Cicero, of all figures,ASME A112.18.1-2012, opined that in some respects the Carthaginian constitution was superior to that of the Greeks, and that their mixed policies reflected an enduring balance. Telle relatives fa? tou le monde croissante de conna?tre l’entraneur de le domaine label,ASME BPVRP,

    Posted on November 4th, 2014 at 4:28 am

  10. AAMI TIR17 Said,

    There is a common / known issue with these with the fuel pressure regulator on the injection pump. It is made from bare copper, with an polyvinyl chloride (PVC) insulation.. But failing that you will need to have it connected up to equipment as I mentioned. Be sure to put your link in the appropriate field. Other areas, as well as the rest of the world,AAMI 11607-2, will follow in 2011.. Demonstrate your knowledge of general maintenance. Bob Lutz,AAMI 14937, the former vice chairman of global pr

    Posted on November 6th, 2014 at 11:06 pm

  11. AATCC 127-1998 Said,

    Flow through ventilation,AATCC 135-2012, an innovation in 1964, was continued in the new generation. I find it hard to believe that anyone could be fool hardy enough to argue it is more dangerous than alcohol. It was as if in that moment I was connected to this crystal and it was connected to me. But since then, things have changed. Decraene holds a Masters Degree in Applied Economics from Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (the Catholic University of Leuven),AATCC 149-2002, Belgium.Fabio GalliaMr.

    Posted on November 7th, 2014 at 3:48 am

  12. SAE ARP 1052B Said,

    On a donc ici un lment contenant le texte balise de dbut peut galement contenir un ou plusieurs attributs, qui sont des paramtres permettant de prciser certaines caractristiques de l’lment. Le nom de la balise dit de faire quelque chose, et un attribut donne des prcisions sur comment le faire. Par exemple,ASHRAE F38-2009 (SI), la balise pour faire un lien est (pour anchor, Mais si on fait juste mon super lien,ANSI/ASHRAE 147-2002, le navigateur ne saura pas o doit mener ce lien.. Valley of the S

    Posted on November 11th, 2014 at 5:09 am

  13. ASME A112.6.3-2001 (R2007) Said,

    Cana,ASME B5.60-2002, as she first appeared in the animeCana is a tall, slim, young woman with an ample bust. She has long,ASME A17.4-1999 (R2009), mid back length brown hair with varying shades of color, having been seen as bright brown,ASME B18.16.4-2008,[2] black,[3] and,ASME B89.7.3.2-2007, ultimately,SAE J 1252, plain brown.[4] Two shoulder length strands of hair frame her face,ASME B107.60-2004, with the left one starting from a prominent, high fringe.[2] Her hair is curlier in the manga t

    Posted on December 1st, 2014 at 9:31 pm

Add A Comment

Your Ad Here